Politics

Actions

Hillary Clinton's Private Emails: What's The Precedent?

Hillary Clinton isn't the first public official to be questioned over the use of emails.
Posted

At best, Hillary Clinton really liked her private email account. At worst, she blatantly disregarded public records laws to keep secret her activities as secretary of state. (Video via U.S. Department of State

Whatever the reason, we now know Clinton exclusively used a personal email address during her four years as America's highest-ranking diplomat, meaning her emails weren't automatically archived for public record. (Video via U.S. Department of State

This was reported first by The New York Times.

Clinton's use of a personal email account raises a lot of questions. Among them: How was this OK? Why didn't anyone insist she use a government email? Were her emails secure from hackers?

Conservatives have asked those same questions and then some. Clinton's potential 2016 challenger, Jeb Bush, recently released hundreds of thousands of emails from his time in office, as he put it, "in the spirit of transparency." 

Of course, Republican officials have gotten in trouble before for doing pretty much the same thing.

"We do not have any indication that there was any basis to conclude that there was any wrongdoing, intentional wrongdoing in the use of the (Republican National Committee) emails," former White House spokeswoman Dana Perino said in 2007.

In 2007, congressional investigators asked the Bush White House to turn over all internal emails relating to the firing of eight U.S. attorneys. But over 5 million emails were either lost or missing. (Video via C-SPAN)

That's because 22 top presidential advisers, including Karl Rove, had conducted business using private email addresses, the archives of which had been deleted.

Clinton's defenders are pointing to the fact that when Colin Powell was secretary of state from 2001 to 2005, he didn't use a government email address either. But there's a big difference there. (Video via U.S. Department of State

As The Times points out, Powell served "before the current regulations went into effect." In other words, he wasn't violating any federal requirements.

On Monday, the State Department confirmed current Secretary of State John Kerry is using an official email account and the emails are being preserved.

This video includes images from Getty Images.