Execution May Set Dangerous Precedent Of Overruling Native Nations
Lezmond Mitchell is the only Native American on death row and may become the first Native to be executed for killing another Native on sovereign land.
When Attorney General William Barr reinstated federal executions in July, it ended a 16-year halt on capital punishment and forced the U.S. government to deal with several unanswered questions — one of which highlights America's long contentious relationship with Native American tribal sovereignty.
Lezmond Mitchell is the only Native American on death row and could become the first Native person in modern American history to be executed by the U.S. government for killing another Native person on sovereign land.
Mitchell, a member of the Navajo Nation, was convicted and sentenced to death for the 2001 murders of Alyce Slim and her nine-year-old granddaughter. Despite the conviction, the Navajo Nation, the federal prosecutor assigned to the case and multiple members of the Slim family recommended that Mitchell not be executed.
The Navajo Nation's statement read: "By subjecting Mr. Mitchell to capital punishment, the Department of Justice has violated our laws and our belief system, … we view this action as both a moral and political affront to Navajo sovereignty."
While the U.S. government has the power to prosecute certain major crimes, like murder, on sovereign lands, tribes can choose whether the crimes are elible for the death penalty. The Navajo Nation, along with the vast majority of American tribes, has opted out of federal executions.
But John Ashcroft, the attorney general at the time, used a legal loophole to pursue the death penalty anyway. He sought execution because the murders took place during a carjacking, which falls under federal authority and does not feature an opt-in or out provision for Native people.
The Navajo Nation believes 'traditional peacemaking' should be a legitimate part of the criminal justice system and said "the negative force that drives a person to commit evil acts can only be extracted by the Creator."
Mitchell's attorney, Jon Aminoff, told Newsy the federal government has largely respected the tribal nations' wishes on capital punishment until now. "There have been at least 20 other instances of murder on tribal land in which the DOJ has considered a capital prosecution, but ultimately declined to do so … This decision violated the spirit, if not the letter, of the Federal Death Penalty Act."
On Friday, Aminoff argued Mitchell's appeal in front of the Ninth Circuit. He claims there was racial bias in the jury that needs investigation because it did not appropriately represent Mitchell's Native peers, since there was only one Navajo on the jury.
As it stands, Mitchell's appeal is the only thing standing between him and execution. Attorney General Barr scheduled five federal executions for the end of 2019 and early 2020. Four of the inmates set to be executed are wrapped up in a lawsuit against Attorney General Barr. Mitchell is not a part of that lawsuit, which means he's not protected by its injunction.
According to the Death Penalty Information Center, 2019 marks the first time in 25 years that a majority of Americans believe life in prison without parole is a better punishment for murder than the death penalty.
Utah law aims to curb teen use of TikTok, Instagram
Utah's governor has signed sweeping legislation aimed at trying to significantly lower use of TikTok and Instagram among young people.
Trump arrested? Putin jailed? Fake AI images spread online
Experts warn that AI-generated images can and will contribute to misinformation, especially online.
TikTok CEO's Capitol Hill testimony raises questions
As lawmakers consider banning TikTok in the U.S., its CEO said "Bans are only appropriate when there are no alternatives."
Are video games contributing to gambling problems?
Experts say the legalization of gambling, especially in mobile settings, is leading to a blurrier line between that and video games.
Ukrainian mom's visit to the US turned into a mission to help refugees
What started as visit to her son in Chicago is now a mission to help other Ukrainian refugees settle in the Windy City.
Woman sues artificial tears maker after loss of eyeball
Ezricare's artificial tears have been linked to a bacterial infection that is causing blindness, loss of eyes and even death.