The Violence Of The New Zealand Mosque Shooting Is Amplified Online
The shooting of two New Zealand mosques is the latest attack to spread violence and extremism online.
Posting on sites like Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and Instagram, the alleged shooter of two New Zealand mosques is the latest to leverage social media to spread violence and extremism online.
Before the attack, police say the alleged gunman posted a racist and Islamophobic manifesto on social media. The attack itself was announced on message boards, and then live-streamed on Facebook. The graphic 17-minute recording of the shooting spread quickly online after.
Tech companies like Twitter, Google and Facebook have announced efforts to remove the attacker's posts and accounts. And representatives from Reddit told the Washington Post the company was "actively monitoring the situation" and removing the video as well.
Despite those efforts, the gruesome video is still constantly being re-uploaded to YouTube. The manifesto is still hosted on sites with little to no oversight. And ultimately, the extremist ideology of the alleged attacker is spreading — and it's worth questioning if these platforms could have stopped it.
"What I would like to do is have an open and honest and frank conversation about the role of Facebook in society. ...We are seeing it weaponized by terrorists and extremist groups, we are seeing it weaponized by people who are exploiting young children, we are seeing it weaponized by bullying, we are seeing it weaponized by drug dealers and people trafficking in illegal weapons."
Hany Farid of the Counter Extremism Project may be talking specifically about Facebook there — but it highlights the broader issue of how major internet platforms can amplify hatred and violence.
In 2015, a white supremacist self-radicalized by online neo-Nazi propaganda killed nine African-Americans in a church in Charleston, South Carolina. Months later, an attacker live-streamed his murder of two Virginia journalists. And just last year, before killing 11 Jews at a Pittsburgh synagogue, the shooter regularly posted hate speech online.
While these shootings are alarming on their own, their connections to online spaces paint a scary picture of how extremism and violence permeate in the digital age.
After the mosque massacre in New Zealand, a New York Times columnist referred to it as "an internet-native mass shooting, conceived and produced entirely within the irony-soaked discourse of modern extremism." The Verge noted the manifesto contained "buzzwords meant to galvanize its spread."
"The platforms have to be held more responsible for the weaponization of their platform, whether that's due to extremism, child exploitation, illegal drugs, illegal weapons, etc. And so, I think that there is a line where we can allow for innovation, allow for free expression but minimize some of the damage we have been seeing to society over the last few years."
Despite years of warnings from terrorism experts and organizations like the Southern Poverty Law Center, the online infrastructure that perpetuates extremism still exists — and the New Zealand gunman's attack will likely continue traveling through it.
Additional reporting from Newsy affiliate CNN.
Suicide bomber kills 47, wounds over 150 at Pakistan mosque
The Pakistani Taliban, also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan or TTP, claimed responsibility for the attack in the northwestern city of Peshawar.By Muhammad Sajjad / AP
Israeli extremist group takes root in US with fundraising bid
An investigation by AP and the watchdog group Shomrim found that money raised through a U.S. nonprofit has gone to convicted Israeli extremists.By Avshalom Sassoni / Pool Photo via AP
Alabama Woman Who Joined IS Hopes To Return From Syria Camp
Hoda Muthana said she was brainwashed by online traffickers into joining the Islamic State in 2014 and regrets everything except her young son.By AP Photo / The News Movement
A real zoodunit: Monkeys found but mystery deepens in Dallas
Dallas police said they safely located two emperor tamarin monkeys that had been missing after their enclosure was cut open.By Dallas Zoo via AP
Tom Brady announces he's retiring … again
"I'm retiring. For good," the 45-year-old quarterback and seven-time Super Bowl champion said in a video posted on social media.By John Raoux / AP
VP Kamala Harris to attend Tyre Nichols' funeral
Nichols will be laid to rest three weeks after he died following a beating by Memphis police.By Nichols family via AP