Gerrymandering Is Absolutely Unfair, But Should SCOTUS Get Involved?
The court typically wants nothing to do with cases that could paint it as a political actor ... and for good reason.
LEARN MORESupreme Court Decides Against Getting Involved In Gerrymandering Cases
The U.S. Supreme Court could have issued landmark opinions against partisan gerrymanders — one from each political party. It didn't.
Supreme Court Decides Against Getting Involved In Gerrymandering Cases
Getty Images
June 18, 2018
On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled against intervening in two high-profile partisan gerrymanders — a Democratic gerrymander in Maryland and a Republican gerrymander in Wisconsin.
In the Maryland case Benisek v. Lamone, plaintiffs had argued election officials shouldn't hold congressional elections under districting maps drawn in 2011 after the 2010 census. A lower court denied the injunction plaintiffs were seeking, and SCOTUS ruled the lower court was justified.
In the Wisconsin case Gill v. Whitford, SCOTUS ruled in part based on the injury to each voter caused by statewide redistricting that favored Republicans. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote: "That harm arises from the particular composition of the voter’s own district, which causes his vote—having been packed or cracked—to carry less weight than it would carry in another, hypothetical district. Remedying the individual voter’s harm, therefore, does not necessarily require restructuring all of the State’s legislative districts."
In Newsy's ongoing series "Ask the Experts," Professor Jay Dow of the Kinder Institute on Constitutional Democracy says the court was loathe to rule on partisan gerrymandering for several reasons, and voters in some parts of the country have already found local solutions to gerrymandering.
2:14
Navajo Nation fights for water access in front of Supreme Court
Navajo Nation was left out of Colorado River allocations as western states fight over its resources. Now they're fighting for reassignments.
3:22
Supreme Court questions Biden's ability to forgive student loans
Proponents of student loan forgiveness point out the rising cost of education in recent decades, while opponents say the plan is too costly.
2:45
Supreme Court weighs Google's liability in ISIS terror case
Justices will look at Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which protects tech firms from being sued over content recommended to users.
Top Stories
Tracking brown macroalgae in the Atlantic Ocean
A large amount of sargassum is floating eastward in the Atlantic Ocean and is expected to create beach hazards as is runs into coastlines.
Multiple students dead following shooting at Nashville school
Three students were killed in a shooting at a Nashville private Christian School on Monday, according to Scripps News Nashville.
3:45
A high school bank is teaching students financial literacy
A bank branch inside Milaca High School is giving students real-world experience managing their money.
