The President

We May Soon Find Out If Trump Can Remove Monuments' Protections

Activists worry the president will remove the protected status of some national monuments that recent presidents put in place.

We May Soon Find Out If Trump Can Remove Monuments' Protections
Getty Images

Can President Donald Trump completely take away a national monument's protection? We may find out.

Trump claims recent presidents, like Barack Obama, abused the Antiquities Act of 1906 — which lets presidents unilaterally give federal lands monument status. 

By executive order, Trump tasked Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke to review roughly two dozen monuments. Currently, they make up millions of acres of protected land and seabed. 

On Thursday, Zinke gave Trump his recommendations as to which monuments he thinks should be scaled down in size.

Statue of Confederate Gen. Robert E. Lee in Charlottesville, Virginia.

Why Confederate Monuments Exist In The First Place

Confederate monuments were erected to remember the Confederacy, but they were also used to intimidate black Americans in the 20th century.


Though he didn't immediately release them to the public, he did tell The Associated Press he wouldn't recommend completely scrapping any monument. Instead, he said he'd push to reduce the size of a "handful" of monuments.

In a summary of his report, Zinke said the boundaries on some monuments are "arbitrary" or "politically motivated."

But conservationists worry Trump will take those recommendations a step further and remove some monuments' designations.

That move would be unprecedented. And whether he really could is up for debate. 

Some, like Democratic Sen. Tom Udall, have already argued the Antiquities Act doesn't give Trump a legal right to remove a designation — mainly because it doesn't explicitly say he can. 

Some legal experts told Politifact similar laws created around the same time as the Antiquities Act specifically said the president could remove the land protections given in those laws. Therefore, the argument goes that if Congress wanted the Antiquities Act to give the president the power to remove designations, it would have said so.

But other legal experts argue a basic guarantee of the Constitution is that the government can reverse any action it was allowed to take in the first place. 

Two legal experts told Politifact the Constitution doesn't explicitly say Congress can undo a law either, but Congress has long shown it's able to do just that by simply creating a new law. 

Activists have threatened legal action if the Trump administration decides to alter or eliminate any national monuments.